The Ultimate Faceoff: Texas vs. California

compare auto insurance california

It’s time for a showdown between two of the largest states in the country. We’re talking about an insurance faceoff. Which state is cheaper for car insurance: Texas or California?

Let’s set the stage for the fight.

Insurance is regulated on the state level, so things that affect your insurance price will be different from state to state. These are called rating factors. A rating factor is any detail about you (think: gender, age, driving record, job) that an insurance company uses to determine how much of a risk they think you are. The riskier they think you are based on the rating factors, typically, the more you will pay.

Ready to meet our competitors?

In the right corner, we’ve got Texas, and to the left, California.

Things that will affect your price in Texas, but not California

compare auto insurance rates by stateOn the whole, in Texas, personal information will affect your price more than in California. Factors like you age, driving record, where you keep your car and the type of car you drive will affect your insurance price.

Two factors that Texas will be looking for that California won’t are:

  • Prior Insurance Status: Just like in the dating game where it seems like guys want you more when you’ve got a boyfriend, insurance companies want people who are also already taken. You’re less of a risk if you’re currently insured, so if you have prior insurance, Texas rating on this factor will help you.
  • Credit: Your credit score is an indicator of financial health. Insurance companies in California can’t take this into consideration when pricing insurance, so your high credit score won’t help you save money. However, credit is a factor that Texas cares about, and having a good credit score will come in handy in getting a deal on insurance.

Factors California cares about but Texas doesn’t

state car insuranceThere is regulation called Proposition 103 that states that the three greatest rating factors in California should be safety record, mileage and driving experience. With that said, these are two qualities that California insurers prioritize:

  • Mileage: How far you drive matters because when you’re in your car more, there’s more opportunities to get into an accident. So if you’re driving very little, the fact that California rates heavily on this will make your price cheaper.
  • Mandated good driver discount: If you’re a good driver, then you’re in luck in California. They ask companies to give you a price break for a clean driving record. Texans, you might get a discount too, but it’s not a guarantee.

Outside of these rating factors, there’s even more that insurance companies look at.  Things like frequency of accidents in the state, population density and other environmental factors that they might need to cover with your premium. But let’s not get into the weeds. Let’s get back to the matchup and declare a winner. Which state has a lower average premium?

The Cheaper State for Insurance

Texas can raise its hands in victory on this fight. On average, a Compare.com customer in California pays $1,893 while Texans pay $1,667.*

Then again, if you currently have an awesome driving history and don’t drive very much, you might end up getting a better deal in California based on their rating factor priorities. Each insurance carrier will also rate you a bit differently depending on their portfolio, so there’s really only one way to know if you could be spending less on insurance, and that’s by comparing prices.

You can switch insurance companies any time you’d like, but comparing locked-in prices before you renew your insurance is the perfect time. Take a few minutes on www.compare.com to see if switching can save you money, or have peace of mind that you’re already getting a good deal.

*Average state premiums are from a sample of auto insurance consumers using compare.com who are over twenty, have one car with at least one year of insurance.

Share This

You could save up to 32% by using Compare.com!

Based on a survey of 100 California Residents. Average savings determined via a comparison of their selected policy against their self-reported annual premium.