Why You Might Want to Pay More for Your Car Insurance

May 15, 2018

Group talking

We’re all about helping people save money on car insurance. You compare auto insurance quotes, you pick the lowest rate, you save. That’s how it works. Right? Well, sometimes it’s actually smarter to pay more for your car insurance. You may want more liability protection or maybe you want a better claims service. Here are a few times when it makes sense to pay a little extra.

To Get More Coverage

I’ve had the same level of liability insurance for 10 years: $25,000/$50,000 per person/accident in bodily injury coverage and $25,000 in property damage liability. Ten-years-ago-me was a student out of college, I didn’t have many assets and I figured I probably couldn’t afford any more.

I didn’t realize that over the past ten years, I’d racked up 10 years of claim-free driving and moved to a safer neighborhood. I got a quote on Compare.com and found that I could more than double the amount of bodily injury coverage — to $100,000/$300,000 — for less than $10 more per month.

To me, the additional peace of mind is well worth the few dollars extra each month for car insurance. You may not need the same amount, but if your current insurance is at state minimum level, you should think about raising the limits to protect yourself.

To Lower Your Deductible

I was happily driving along the I-95 a few weeks ago and… crack. A rock hit my windshield and it was too big to repair, I needed a whole new windshield. Now not so happy. Even less happy when I realized that I’d set my deductible to $1,000 thinking it would save me some money. I ended up paying for the entire windshield out of pocket. Big sad face.

Most financial gurus will tell you to choose a higher deductible in order to save money on your car insurance premiums. But that’s not always a good deal. If you save $50 per year on premiums by raising your deductible from $250 to $750, you’ll have to stay accident-free for 10 years to come out ahead. It may be smarter for you to pay a little more in car insurance premiums in exchange for less out of pocket costs if you need to claim.

You’re All About The Designer Brands

You can probably list off a few car insurance companies right now. And there’s a reason for that. Insurance companies spend millions every year making sure you know their name and how do you think they finance that? That’s right: your premiums.

The benefits of going with a larger, better-known insurer is that you can take advantage of their more expensive resources. Longer customer service hours, brick and mortar offices, local agents, mobile claims units – all of these come at a price. Although, just because you’ve heard of the brand name doesn’t guarantee you those things. Smaller insurers often team up with larger companies to pool resources. Check out our companies guides to see what benefits different insurers can offer you.

Think you’re getting a loyalty discount by sticking with your insurer for five years or more? Nope — the company’s probably charging you extra, because they know you’re less likely to leave.

Your Current Insurer is Garbage

On the other side of the spectrum, you may feel stuck with a company that done you wrong. You were happy with ‘super-cheap car insurance Inc’ — until you got into a fender-bender. It should have been an easy claim, these things happen all the time, right? Not for your insurer. They kept you on hold for hours, tried to charge you extra and generally turned a simple claim into a nightmare.

It’s time to compare auto insurance and upgrade to a better company, even if that means paying a little more. Look at some reviews and ask your friends and family for recommendations. Think about what you want in an insurer: local branches, 24/7 claims service, good sense of humor… Read our guide to finding the best cheap insurance and what to look for.

Your Life is Expensive

A fancy sports car, a house in the suburbs, kids… these things all have one thing in common: they’re expensive. If you’ve wondered, “how much car insurance do I need?”, your net worth is the answer. When you were a college student with about $5,000 worth of possessions, you didn’t worry too much about getting into a car accident and being sued for everything you owned. Now, however, you may own a house and have some money set aside — and that means you should protect your assets.

Whatever reasoning you may have behind being ready to pay a bit more, it doesn’t mean you should pay a lot more. Most of these may only be an extra few dollars a month and if you do your research, you may even pay less than your current premium. Compare car insurance prices with Compare.com today and see how much you can save!

Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Share This

Enter your info. Compare companies. Lock-in your price. Be done.