Nearly 3 in 5 Surveyed Borrowers Are Still Paying for Last Year’s Holidays
For many households, last year’s holiday spending never really ended.
While 58% of surveyed borrowers are still paying off purchases from the 2025 holiday season, more than 1 in 3 Americans carrying debt (36%) are paying off last year’s purchases on credit cards. Only 1 in 8 are still making personal loan payments, which typically carry lower interest rates than credit cards.
The type of financing shoppers choose can affect the total cost of their holiday purchase due to fees and interest. Based on the average APRs shown below, a $100 balance carried for one year with no payments or added charges would accrue nearly twice as much interest on a credit card as on a personal loan.
What Financing Costs for Every $100 in Spending
| | | | |
|---|
| Short-term BNPL | 0% | 6 weeks | $0.00 | $100 |
|---|
| Long-term BNPL | 26% | 12 months | $14.64 | $114.64 |
|---|
| Credit card | 22.36% | 12 months | $12.52 | $112.52 |
|---|
| Personal loan | 11.90% | 12 months | $6.56 | $106.56 |
|---|
Disclaimer: Costs assume on-time payments and no fees. APRs use Fed benchmarks and PayPal’s 26% BNPL example, not a market average. Interest-bearing balances are modeled over 12 months, using a 24-month rate benchmark for personal loans.
But the growth of buy now, pay later (BNPL) loan debt is particularly noteworthy. Our Compare.com survey shows that 30% of surveyed borrowers are still making BNPL payments on some of their 2025 holiday purchases.
BNPL is a fast-growing form of short-term credit, typically offered with no credit check and 0% financing. The share of U.S. households carrying BNPL debt rose from 7% in 2022 to 12% in 2025, according to the Federal Reserve.[3]
Even as many continue to pay for last year’s holidays, 46% of Americans carrying debt plan to increase their holiday budgets this year. With inflation and tariffs pushing up the cost of many gifts, spending more doesn’t necessarily mean buying more. For shoppers financing their purchases, interest could drive the final cost even higher.
70% of married or partnered parents still carry holiday debt
Parents carry more holiday debt than non-parents. Nearly two-thirds (64%) are still paying off last year’s purchases, compared to about half (51%) of non-parents. The added financial demands of celebrating with children often extend gift-giving to teachers, caregivers, and school parties.
Compare.com also found that married or partnered parents reported more lingering holiday debt (70%) than single parents (66%), but that alone doesn’t mean they’re struggling more financially. Households with two adults may have more combined income and greater borrowing capacity to support that debt.
)