At Compare.com, it’s our mission to find simple ways to help our customers save money on the things they need. While we partner with some of the companies and brands we talk about in our articles, all of our content is written and reviewed by our independent editorial team and never influenced by our partnerships. Learn about how we make money, review our editorial standards, and reference our data methodology to learn more about why you can trust Compare.com.
- Just Insure is the cheapest insurance company overall with an average liability premium of just $50/mo.
- Hugo offers the best rates for teens and young drivers under 25 years old.
- Aspire is the most affordable insurer for liability coverage ($44/mo) and 21st Century is cheapest for full coverage policies ($109/m0).
- Comparing quotes from different insurance companies is the best way to find affordable coverage.
It’s no secret that car insurance rates are on the rise. In fact, they have been increasing steadily for the past few years. However, this doesn’t mean that you have to break the bank in order to insure your vehicle. There are a number of ways that you can save on car insurance, even in 2023.
In this article, we’ll discuss some of the most affordable car insurance companies and how to uncover the best rates. So whether you are looking for cheap auto insurance for your new car or want to find more affordable coverage for your family, read on for expert tips on how to save.
In This Article:
- Top 5 Cheapest Car Insurance Companies
- Cheapest Companies for Bad Drivers
- Cheapest Companies by Coverage Type
- Cheapest Companies by Age Group
- Cheapest Companies for Men vs. Women
- Cheapest Companies by State
- Best Ways to Save on Your Bill
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Top 5 Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in 2023
One of the most affordable car insurance companies in 2022 is a smaller company you may not have heard of — Just Insure. With monthly premiums of just $50, this lesser-known “pay-per-mile” company offers some of the best rates on the market.
Another affordable option is Aspire, which offers average rates of just $57 per month. This company is known for its wide range of coverage options and reliable customer service, making it a great choice for those looking for affordable car insurance.
But when it comes to finding cheap car insurance, there are a number of factors that can influence your rates. Some of these include your driving record, the type and age of your vehicle, and the coverage options you choose. Keep reading to find out how each factor can affect your premiums and find out which company has the cheapest rates for teens, retirees, married drivers, bad drivers, students, foreign drivers, and more.
The Cheapest Major Auto Insurer: American Family Insurance
American Family Insurance offers the most affordable premiums on average for both liability and full coverage policies.
|Average Liability Premium||$879|
|Average Full Coverage Premium||$1,727|
|Advantages||Offer numerous discount opportunities, receives fewer complaints than many companies of the same size, customize your coverage with specialty insurance options|
|Disadvantages||Limited availability in the United States|
American Family, also known as AmFam, is the 10th largest insurer in the United States, offering affordable coverage. Founded in 1927, it has built a reputation for serving many customers with affordable policies and providing quality coverage and customer service.
Check out the table below to see how American Family compares to some of the other cheapest major insurance companies.
|Insurance Company||Average Liability Premium||Average Full Coverage Premium|
|American Family Insurance||$879||$1,727|
Drivers with American Family can enroll in telematics and accident forgiveness programs to keep premiums low. Several discount options are also available, including the multi-policy discount, good driver discount, safety equipment discount, defensive driver discount, pay-in-full discount, and more.
Regarding coverage, you have various options, including gap insurance, ridesharing coverage, accident forgiveness, and original equipment manufacturer coverage. While there are many advantages to selecting AmFam insurance, one downside is it only covers drivers in 19 states.
Related: How to Lower Your Car Insurance the Right Way
The Cheapest Companies for Drivers with a Clean Driving History: American National Insurance Company
American National Insurance Company offers the most affordable premiums to drivers with no tickets, accidents, or DUIs on their record.
|Average Liability Premium||$461|
|Average Full Coverage Premium||$1,155|
|Advantages||High user satisfaction rating, available in all 50 states, several money saving options are available, including a cash-back program and discounted or no deductible if you’re in an accident with an American National customer|
|Disadvantages||Few discount offerings compared to other insurers|
American National Insurance Company was founded in 1905. It offers a variety of insurance coverages including auto, home and life insurance, so you can bundle your coverage.
Check out the table below to see how American National compares to some of the other cheapest insurance companies for drivers with a clean record.
|Insurance Company||Average Liability Premium||Average Full Coverage Premium|
|American National Insurance Company||$461||$1,155|
|American Select Insurance Company||$685||$2,126|
|Farm Bureau Financial Services||$731||$2,186|
The Cheapest Companies for Drivers After a Speeding Ticket: American National Insurance Company
American National Insurance Company also offers the most affordable premiums for drivers with a speeding ticket on their record.
|Average Liability Premium||$599|
|Average Full Coverage Premium||$1,423|
|Advantages||The mobile app is user friendly, sells gap insurance and the added coverage endorsement, offers 12 types of insurance coverage|
|Disadvantages||The website doesn’t offer many details about auto or home insurance discounts.|
Check out the table below to see how American National compares to some of the other cheapest insurance companies for drivers with a ticket on their record.
|Insurance Company||Average Liability Premium||Average Full Coverage Premium|
|American National Insurance Company||$599||$1,423|
|American Select Insurance Company||$903||$2,685|
Related: Cheap Car Insurance for High-Risk Drivers
Compare car insurance to get affordable coverage in minutes
The Cheapest Companies for Drivers With a DUI: American National Insurance Company
If you have a DUI on your record, you’ll find the most affordable premiums with American National Insurance Company
|Average Liability Premium||$767|
|Average Full Coverage Premium||$1,735|
View the table below to see how American National compares to some of the other affordable insurance companies for drivers with a DUI.
|Insurance Company||Average Liability Premium||Average Full Coverage Premium|
|American National Insurance Company||$767||$1,735|
Cheap Liability Insurance Companies: Aspire
If you are looking for the cheapest possible car insurance policy, there are a few companies that stand out for plans with minimal coverage. Aspire, for example, offers some of the most affordable state minimum coverage plans, with monthly premiums as low as $44.
Other cheap options for state minimum insurance include Shelter Mutual and 21st Century. Both of these companies offer reliable coverage at an affordable price, making them ideal choices for anyone looking to save on their car insurance costs.
Learn More: How to Get Cheap Liability Insurance
However, keep in mind that you may need more extensive coverage than just the state minimum if you have a newer or more expensive vehicle. That’s where “full coverage” policies come into play. More on that below:
Cheap Full Coverage Insurance Companies: 21st Century
You may have heard people referring to “full coverage” car insurance policies, but “full” coverage isn’t actually an official category when it comes to auto insurance, so it can mean a few different things depending on who you ask.
Typically, “full coverage” car insurance often refers to policies that provide both comprehensive and collision coverage. These plans can help protect your vehicle in the event of accidents, theft, vandalism, or any other type of damage. But it can also include things like uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (UIM), personal injury protection (PIP), medical payments coverage (MedPay), and other additional coverages.
But when it comes to cheap full coverage car insurance (in this case, we’re referring to liability + comprehensive and collision), 21st Century is one of the most affordable options available. With monthly premiums averaging just $109, they offer reliable coverage at a price that most drivers can afford.
Other cheap options for full coverage include Hugo and First Chicago. Both of these companies offer reliable plans with monthly premiums starting at around $113, making them ideal choices for anyone looking to save on their car insurance costs.
However, it’s important to keep in mind that the rates offered by different companies can vary depending on a number of factors, so you should always compare quotes from multiple providers before making your final decision. With a little bit of research and shopping around, you can find cheap car insurance for drivers with all different types of driving records and get the coverage you need at a great price.
Learn More: How to Get the Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance
Save on your next car insurance policy.
The Cheapest Car Insurance Rates by Age Group
Age can play a big role in how much you pay for car insurance, and rates vary significantly depending on how old you are and how long you’ve been driving. Generally speaking, younger drivers tend to pay more for car insurance, while older drivers can sometimes find cheap coverage.
Here are a few of the cheapest companies based on age group:
Cheap Car Insurance Rates for Teens: Hugo
If you are a teen or young adult, one of the most important things to focus on is finding cheap car insurance. Many young drivers pay more than they need to for coverage, simply because they lack experience and have higher accident rates.
Related: How to Get Cheap Car Insurance for New Drivers
Hugo is one of the cheapest options available for teens, with monthly premiums starting at just $140. They offer solid coverage at an affordable price, making them a great choice for young drivers looking to save on car insurance. Not only that, but Hugo allows you to fully customize the length of your policy, allowing drivers to pay for car insurance for just a few days or a week at a time. That extra layer of flexibility can help drivers searching for cheaper car insurance better afford their new policy. Win-win.
Other cheap options for teen drivers include Gainsco and Dairyland, with monthly premiums starting at around $175 and $178 respectively.
Cheap Car Insurance Rates for Young Drivers Under 25: Hugo
As a young driver, you may also be looking for cheap car insurance rates. In general, young drivers tend to pay more than older drivers due to their increased risk of accidents and higher accident rates. However, there are still plenty of cheap options out there that can help you get the coverage that you need at an affordable price, especially if you’re a student or a recent college grad.
Again, Hugo is one of the cheapest options for young drivers, offering monthly premiums starting at just $126. They offer flexible coverage at a competitive price, making them a great choice for young drivers looking to save on their car insurance costs.
Other cheap options for young drivers include Commonwealth Casualty, Clearcover, and Mile Auto. All of these companies offer competitive rates with monthly premiums starting at around $135, $139, and $146 respectively. So if you’re looking for cheap car insurance as a young driver, be sure to compare rates from these and other top providers to find the plan that best fits your needs.
Learn More: How to Get Cheaper Car Insurance Young Drivers
Find the best rates for young drivers today.
Cheap Car Insurance Rates for Retired Drivers: Mile Auto
As a retired driver, you may be looking for affordable car insurance that meets your needs without breaking the bank. In general, older drivers tend to pay less for car insurance due to their lower risk of accidents and reduced accident rates.
Mile Auto is one of the cheapest options available for retired drivers, with monthly premiums starting at just $66. With rates nearly 40% cheaper than average, this makes Mile Auto a great choice for retired drivers looking to save on their car insurance costs.
Other cheap options for retired drivers include Dairyland, Clearcover, and Mercury. These companies offer competitive rates with monthly premiums starting at around $73, $84, and $87 respectively.
The Cheapest Car Insurance Companies for Men vs. Women
Just like age, gender is another factor that’s out of your control, but can still affect your car insurance rates. Generally speaking, men tend to pay more for car insurance than women due to their higher risk of accidents and greater accident rates. However, there are still a few cheap options that offer competitive rates for men and women alike.
Cheap Car Insurance Companies for Men: Aspire
As one of the cheapest car insurance companies for men, Aspire offers monthly premiums starting at just $58. They may be a smaller company (like many on this list), but their competitive rates make them a great choice for male drivers looking to save on their car insurance costs.
Other cheap options for men include Sun Coast, Commonwealth Casualty, Shelter Mutual, and Metromile. All of these companies offer affordable monthly premiums ranging from $76 to $83, making them a great choice for men looking to save on their car insurance.
Cheap Car Insurance Companies for Women: Aspire
Just as with men, Aspire offers the best rates for women drivers, with monthly premiums starting at just $57. They offer extremely competitive rates when compared to the other companies on this list, making them a great choice for female drivers looking to save on their car insurance costs.
Other cheap options for women include Sun Coast, Shelter Mutual, Commonwealth Casualty, and Dairyland. All of these companies offer affordable monthly premiums ranging from $77 to $85, making them the go-to providers for cheap car insurance that meets the needs of women drivers.
The Cheapest Car Insurance Companies by State
|State||Carrier||Avg. Monthly Premium|
|New Jersey||Plymouth Rock||$134|
|North Carolina||Liberty Mutual||$70|
|Rhode Island||Liberty Mutual||$298|
|South Carolina||Liberty Mutual||$119|
|Washington, D.C.||Liberty Mutual||$158|
|West Virginia||Liberty Mutual||$81|
The cheapest car insurance companies vary depending on where you live. For example, in Alabama and Arizona, cheap options include Gainsco and Mercury, with average monthly premiums of just $59 in both states. In other states like Arkansas, Colorado, and Delaware, cheap providers include DirectGeneral, Aspire, and Liberty Mutual, with monthly premiums ranging from $79 to $173.
To find the cheapest car insurance companies in your state, simply consult our comprehensive list above.
Learn more: Which States Have the Cheapest Car Insurance?
The Key to Cheaper Car Insurance is Comparing Quotes
The average Compare.com user saves $720 a year just by comparing.
Some insurance companies use a tactic called price optimization, which means they nudge up the current customer’s price a little each year. If you haven’t compared car insurance quotes recently, this might be happening to you and you haven’t even noticed!
Plus, there are hundreds of car insurance companies out there. What are the chances that the one company you selected is the cheapest car insurance for you? Unless you are comparing prices, you won’t know how much you could be saving.
In one comparison, a woman in Texas got prices that ranged from $77 a month to $300 by using Compare.com. That’s over $2,600 in savings every year from taking just a few minutes to compare companies and find the best cheap car insurance rates.
What You Need to Get a Cheap Car Insurance Policy
Finding cheaper car insurance is a whole lot easier than you think! You don’t need to make any phone calls to agents. You don’t need to fill out forms on different insurers’ sites. All you need is one site: Compare.com.
Comparing quotes and uncovering cheaper rates is completely free and doesn’t require submitting any private information. It does help to know:
- Your current insurance limits
- When your current policy expires
- How many miles you drive each year
- The approximate dates and details of any accidents or moving violations in the past three years
Learn More: How to Find Very Cheap Car Insurance
The 7 Best Ways to Save Money on Your Auto Insurance
While there are some factors you can’t control when it comes to how much you pay for car insurance, there are a few ways you can help yourself find cheaper auto insurance coverage, including...
Look For Discounts
Most insurers offer a menu of car insurance discounts that can snag you significant savings on your policy.
Some of the best discounts:
A multi-car discount for insuring more than one vehicle can save you 25% or more on your premium, compared to insuring the cars separately.
A multi-policy discount can save you up to 25% if you bundle your car insurance with your home or renters insurance or other policies, such as life insurance.
Discounts for paying your policy in full or setting up automatic payments can get you savings of up to 10%.
Discounts for certain vehicle features are small, but they add up! You can save on car insurance if your vehicle has anti-theft systems, air bags, anti-lock brakes and other safety features.
Some insurers give discounts to good students, accident-free drivers, military veterans and members of certain organizations or groups.
Discounts are great — but you should know that they don’t always save you as much as you might expect. Read the fine print, and you may see that your discount for having air bags (for example) only applies to your premium for medical payments coverage.
Raise Your Deductible
Choosing a higher deductible is a sure-fire way to get cheaper car insurance. But is it worth it? That depends on your financial situation… and whether you’re a risk taker.
A car insurance deductible is the money you personally pay toward an accident or a claim before your insurance policy pays the rest. Typically, you have a deductible for your comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist property damage, and personal injury protection coverages.
The higher your deductible, the less your insurer has to pay after an accident. So your auto insurance rates get cheaper if you choose a $500 or a $1,000 deductible, compared to a $250 deductible.
That can be tempting… but what if you get into a fender-bender that causes $1,200 worth of damage, and you have a $1,000 deductible? Will you be able to pay?
Take a good hard look at your finances and driving record and see if a higher deductible is something you can swing. After all, it could save you a lot of money in the long run if you don’t file many claims.
Practice Safe Driving
All the discounts and high deductibles in the world can’t get you a cheap car insurance policy if you have a bad driving record.
How much does your car insurance go up after a ticket? Usually, around 20 to 30%, depending on whether the ticket is for a minor traffic violation or something more serious, like reckless driving.
How much does your car insurance go up after an accident? More than 40%, on average, according to Forbes Advisor. And that’s if you had a clean driving record to start with.
This means that one of the most effective ways to get cheap car insurance is to do your best to drive safely, avoid accidents and obey the speed limit. If you already have a few oopsies on your record, just be patient. They’ll fall off after 3 to 5 years, and then your insurance rates will go down.
Adjust Your Coverage Limits (Within Reason)
The cheapest auto insurance will almost always be state minimum insurance. It makes sense: the less coverage you have, the less you should pay, right?
Just bear in mind that car insurance exists to protect you from financial losses in the event of an accident. State minimum insurance doesn’t include collision and comprehensive coverage for your own vehicle. And if your insurance has a maximum liability payout of $40,000, and you cause a three-car pileup resulting in $90,000 of damage and medical bills, then you’re on the hook for the remainder.
Nevertheless, there’s a lot of wiggle room between the absolute cheapest car insurance and expensive, full-coverage insurance. Compare quotes to see how much you can save.
Sign-up For Telematics or Usage-Based Insurance
Opting for a pay-per-mile policy is one of the best ways to get cheap auto insurance — if you drive less than the average person. With pay-per-mile insurance, you pay a monthly base rate as low as $29, then a per-mile rate on top of that. An app or electronic device tracks your miles driven.
From an insurance company’s perspective, it makes sense: the less you drive, the smaller your chance of getting into an accident! Pay-per-mile company Metromile says its customers save 47% on average, compared to a traditional auto insurance policy.
Telematics insurance, aka usage-based insurance, is a little different. These policies track not only how much you drive, but how safely you drive. You consent to let your insurance company track your driving — short-term or permanently — and then you get a discount based on your habits. Many drivers find that the maximum advertised discount is really hard to get, however. With usage-based insurance, you’ll get dinged for braking hard, driving late at night, accelerating too quickly and speeding. A realistic discount may be around 10-15%.
Work on Your Credit Score
Did you know that your credit can affect your car insurance rates? In most states (but not all), insurers can consider your credit history when they’re setting your premiums.
They use something called a credit-based insurance score, which is similar to — but not identical to — your normal credit score. The credit-based insurance score is based on your track record of making payments on time, the amount of debt you currently have, the length of your credit history, and other factors.
Credit can have a surprisingly large impact on your insurance rates, and unfortunately, there’s no quick fix. Just work on improving your credit by making timely payments and paying down debt.
If your credit suffered because of something that wasn’t your fault, such as fraud or a medical emergency, it may be worth contacting your car insurer and explaining the circumstances, to see if they can give you a break.
Learn more: Why You Should Shop for Car Insurance After Paying Off Debt
Compare Quotes from Multiple Companies
When people ask, “What’s the best way to find cheap car insurance?”, there’s a simple answer: Compare personalized quotes.
All you have to do is enter some basic information about yourself, including your address, vehicle make and model, current insurance info, etc. Then, choose which level of coverage you want: minimum, basic, plus or premium. Looking at real-life quotes side by side will show you the range of possible premiums and tell you which companies are offering the best deal.
Cheap Car Insurance FAQs
Who has the cheapest auto insurance?
There is no single company that offers the cheapest car insurance for every person. Each car insurance company has its own ways of judging risk and setting rates, so one company’s quote could be hundreds of dollars less — or more — than another’s. So simply asking “Who has the cheapest car insurance?” won’t get you anywhere. You need to run the numbers for yourself and compare them.
Where can I find the cheapest car insurance?
Often, the answer is: Not where you expect! As you can see in the charts above, the companies offering the cheapest car insurance aren’t always the big, brand-name insurers that advertise big savings and low rates. Smaller insurance companies, specialty insurers, and regional companies all may offer better rates. The best way to find out is to compare quotes.
How much car insurance do I really need?
Great question! There are a lot of factors that come into play, but here’s a quick cheat-sheet to tell you how much car insurance you need.
Are you on a really tight budget and driving an old car? If yes, then you might choose state minimum insurance, which is the cheapest option that lets you drive legally.
Do you drive a newer car, or do you have a car loan? If yes, then you should have collision and comprehensive coverage.
Do you have assets to protect, such as a house or savings account? If yes, then you need full coverage auto insurance with higher limits; at least 50/100/50, or 100/300/100, if possible.
Should car insurance increase every year?
It’s normal for your auto insurance premiums to increase each year. But that doesn’t mean you have to accept it! Insurers may raise rates because you had an at-fault accident, because you filed a claim, because their costs went up, or just because they want to. If you feel like your insurance rates keep rising and it’s not your fault, then compare quotes from multiple companies to find a better deal.
At what age does car insurance go down?
Drivers generally see a decrease in car insurance rates once they turn 19, and a more substantial drop when they turn 25. After that, insurance rates keep going down with age until you turn 60 or 65.
Can I get one-day car insurance?
Unless you’re renting a car, you probably can’t get car insurance just for one day. Insurers typically sell policies lasting a minimum of 6 months. If you really need one-day insurance, you may be able to purchase a 6-month policy and then cancel it.
All of the average rates and other data found in this article are compiled from millions of car insurance quotes from real users on Compare.com. All data is up-to-date as of the publishing date.
Compare.com’s #1 goal is to save you money. We publish resources that are based on hard-hitting data and years of industry experience to help you make more informed decisions with your wallet.
- All of Compare.com’s content is written and reviewed for accuracy by a team of experienced writers and editors who are experts on the topics they cover.
- None of Compare.com’s content is ever influenced by the companies and brands we partner with.
- Compare.com’s editorial team operates independently of any of the company’s partnership or business development interests. We publish unbiased information strictly for the benefit of our readers.
- All of the content you see on Compare.com is based on comprehensive analysis and all data is gathered and vetted from trustworthy sources.
Learn more about us, our team, and what makes us tick.