How to Find Cheap Car Insurance in Florida in 2022

Looking for car insurance in the sunshine state? Look no further than our guide to cheap car insurance in Florida. We’re on a mission to help you find affordable coverage without sacrificing quality no matter your stage in life or driving history.

by Nick Versaw Updated February 28th, 2022

Florida drivers pay an average of a little over $1,425 a month for car insurance, according to data from the Insurance Information Institute. That’s about 35% more than the national average. But that doesn’t mean you’re stuck paying more for car insurance if you live in the Sunshine State. Keep reading to find the cheapest rates Florida has to offer and other ways to save on your next auto insurance policy.


In This Article:


The Cheapest Car Insurance Rates Florida has to Offer

Street and Miami skyline

There are hundreds of different companies advertising affordable car insurance to drivers in Florida, but how are you supposed to know which one is actually the cheapest? We’ve analyzed thousands of real-life quotes to help you find which companies are offering the cheapest average rates for drivers of all types. Check out the sections below to find out which companies offer the most affordable prices for drivers like you.

The Cheapest Rates for Teen Driver in Florida

Finding affordable car insurance for teenage drivers in Florida is easier than you might think. Unlike some states, many auto insurers are willing to take a chance on young drivers. We’ve listed six companies that will give you more affordable insurance as a teen.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Assurance America $173
Gainsco $196
Direct Auto $204
Infinity $236
Esurance $280
Answer Financial $286

First on the list is Assurance America. They provide the cheapest car insurance premiums for teenage drivers in Florida, with monthly liability insurance costing $173 per month. Next on the list, from most affordable to most expensive, are Gainsco ($196/mo.), Direct Auto ($204/mo.), Infinity ($236/mo.), Esurance ($280/mo.), and Answer Financial ($286/mo.).

These are pretty affordable auto rates for teens; however, additional discounts may be available for your young driver. Ask auto insurers if your teen qualifies for one or more of the following discount programs:

Good Student Discount. For teenagers who are in high school or college and are earning top grades. To earn this discount, most auto insurers require the teen driver to maintain an average grade of B or higher.

Telematics Teenage Driver Discount. This program encourages safe driving habits by monitoring your behavior behind the wheel via an app that’s installed in your vehicle. The app factors in how many miles you drive and the hours you’re on the road. It also considers your driving style, such as hard and frequent braking and driving at high speeds.

Teenager Safe Driving Course Discount. Many auto insurers reward discounts to inexperienced, teenage drivers who take driver education courses to understand the road rules better. Some courses can be taken online and will include interactive lessons with 3D animation and video.


Save hundreds by comparing quotes today!


Cheapest Quotes for Florida’s Young Drivers

When drivers turn 25, they can expect to see a sharp reduction in their auto insurance premiums. However, young drivers between the ages of 18 – 24 will still pay higher than average rates for auto insurance. But there is hope; we’ve found seven of the cheapest insurance companies in Florida for young drivers.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $127
Assurance America $139
Infinity $168
Direct Auto $170
Gainsco $172
Answer Financial $215
Esurance $227

At only $127 monthly, Dairyland takes the top spot as the cheapest auto insurance for young Florida drivers. They are followed closely by Assurance America at $139/mo. You then see a $30 jump in insurance rates with Infinity at $168/mo, followed by Direct Auto ($170/mo) and Gainsco ($172/mo). There’s then another larger rate increase with Answer Financial at $215/mo and Esurance at $227/mo.

If you compare the rates for young drivers with teen drivers, you see a decrease in monthly rates. The most affordable rate for young drivers ($127/mo) is over $45 cheaper than it is for teen drivers ($173/mo). You see this trend reflected in all the average monthly rates for young drivers. With young drivers, only 2 of the 7 options listed are above the $200 mark, while teen drivers only have 2 out of 6 options under $200. The most expensive insurer on the list is $14 away from $300 a month!

But your search for the cheapest car insurance in Florida can be just a few quotes away. Shop around to find the best options based on your specific insurance needs. Be sure to ask for all available discounts and compare apples to apples when considering your auto insurance cost.

Cheap Car Insurance for Retired Drivers in California

Are you a retired Florida driver? If the answer is “yes,” you’re in luck. While rates often increase slightly as you hit 65+ it doesn’t mean you have to settle for unaffordable rates. This is important because once you’re no longer working you need to save where you can.

Take a look at four of the cheapest auto insurance premiums for retired drivers in Florida.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Infinity $100
Direct Auto $100
Esurance $132
Liberty Mutual $180

Auto insurance companies like Infinity and Direct Auto, provide the cheapest insurance premiums at $100 per month. Our list also includes Esurance ($132/mo) and Liberty Mutual ($180/mo.).

While the rates we’ve provided are cost-effective, there may be additional savings to be had. Take time to shop around for additional insurance quotes. With a difference of $80/mo between insurers, it’s no surprise that retirees are looking for ways to save money.  Disclose your past or current affiliations with banks, credit unions, professional organizations, sororities and fraternities, community groups, non-profit organizations, as well as companies you’ve worked for. Finding the cheapest car insurance in Florida may be a lot easier than you think.

The Best Rates for Married Drivers in Florida

Being a married driver in Florida will usually get you cheaper auto insurance. That’s because married drivers are seen as less risky to insurance providers. Below, we’ve identified eight of the most affordable auto premiums for married drivers in Florida.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Assurance America $81
Infinity $95
Gainsco $100
Acceptance $115
Esurance $156
Answer Financial $164
Liberty Mutual $210

As you can see, Assurance America offers a liability policy that’s easy on your wallet at just $81/mo. They’re followed by Infinity ($95/mo), Gainsco ($100/mo), Acceptance ($115/mo), Esurance ($156/mo), Answer Financial ($164/mo), and Liberty Mutual ($210/mo).

Cheapest Quotes for Single Drivers

Being single has its benefits, but not necessarily when it comes to finding the cheapest car insurance rates in Florida. Married couples tend to fare better in this area but rest assured, we’ve researched some of the top companies to find affordable premiums for single drivers.

Take a look at nine of the cheapest auto insurance premiums we found for single drivers in Florida.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $91
Assurance America $99
Infinity $113
Direct Auto $121
Gainsco $126
Acceptance $144
Mercury $154
Travelers $158
Safeco $158

Dairyland offers the most affordable auto insurance at just $91/mo.  Assurance America offers a similar rate of $99/mo. Infinity ($113/mo), Direct Auto ($121/mo), and Gainsco ($126/mo) offer similar rates as well. You start to see rates increase with Acceptance at $144/mo, Mercury at $154/mo, Travelers at $158/mo, and Safeco at $158/mo.

Compared with married drivers, single drivers are paying more on average for car insurance. While the cheapest option for married drivers is $81/mo, the cheapest insurer for single drivers sees them paying a monthly premium of $91/mo. While a $10 difference may seem small, it’s still worth shopping around to see if you can find cheaper rates.

The Cheapest Companies for Men vs. Women

Top 5 Cheapest Companies for Men in Florida

Surprisingly, male drivers can expect to fork over a little less than women in Florida when paying auto insurance premiums. Although men are generally viewed as a higher risk group than women, we found men have lower premiums at all but one of the 5 most affordable car insurance companies listed below.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $86
Assurance America $90
Infinity $107
Direct Auto $116
Gainsco $129

Top 5 Cheapest Companies for Women in Florida

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $94
Assurance America $103
Infinity $112
Gainsco $119
Direct Auto $124

See for yourself – we found the same five auto insurers offering the cheapest car insurance to men and women in Florida. Dairyland, Assurance America, Infinity, and Direct Auto were the most affordable for both genders. However, Gainsco was the sole insurer offering slightly cheaper rates for women ($119/mo) than men ($129/mo).

The Most Affordable Rates for Floridians with Spotty Driving Records

Woman getting a speeding ticket

Cheap Car Insurance for Drivers with a Ticket on their Record

Having one ticket on your record may feel like the start of higher premiums, but it doesn’t have to be the case. Depending on the infraction and the insurance provider, the impact on your premiums may be insignificant.

To be on the safe side, immediately take a driver safety course to offset any negative points you may receive due to the traffic ticket. Check out the companies we found with the cheapest rates for drivers with an infraction on their record.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $96
Assurance America $102
Infinity $121
Gainsco $124
Direct Auto $133

Rates start at just $96/mo with Dairyland followed by Assurance America at $102/mo. You then see a rate increase with Infinity at $121/mo, Gainsco at $124/mo and Direct Auto at $133/mo.

Cheapest Rates for People with Multiple Tickets

Most of us have been ticketed at least once for driving over the speed limit, failing to yield, or even making an illegal u-turn. But suppose you’ve received tickets for multiple violations, especially in a short period. In that case, chances are you’ll be forking over more each month in insurance premiums.

Below, we’ve created a list of five of the most affordable auto insurers offering coverage to drivers with multiple tickets on their driving record.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Infinity $125
Assurance America $143
Direct Auto $155
Gainsco $163
Acceptance $174

You can see a significant difference in rates when you have one ticket vs. multiple tickets. The most affordable rate is $125/mo with Infinity. Rates then continue to increase with Assurance America ($143/mo), Direct Auto ($155/mo), and Gainsco ($163/mo). Auto insurance rates top off at $174/mo with Acceptance.

Drivers who choose Gainsco as their insurer will see a stark increase in rates when they go from one ticket to multiple tickets. While a driver with a single ticket will pay $124/mo, a driver with multiple tickets will need to hand over a hefty $163/mo. This difference of nearly $40 means that you could pay over $450 more for car insurance  in a year! 

Since your driving record is one of the factors used by insurance companies to determine your insurance premium, drivers with tickets can save in other areas. Consider bundling your home and car insurance or taking a state approved driving course to save money.

Cheap Insurance for Drivers with an Accident on their Record

Whether you’re at fault or not, being involved in an automobile accident can be scary and stressful.

First things first, contact your insurance company to not only report the accident but to find out if they forgive first-time offenders. If they do, your insurance rates will not go up. If not, you’re likely to experience a rise in your insurance rates.

Either way, take this opportunity to do some research to find the cheapest car insurance for drivers with an accident on their record. In the meantime, check out five companies that we found offer the most affordable rates.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Assurance America $125
Infinity $137
Gainsco $151
Acceptance $173
Direct Auto $176

Assurance America offers an average liability coverage rate of $125/mo. Direct Auto rounds out the list at $176/mo, so you see a $50/mo difference between the least and most expensive options available.

While we found these rates based on our research, be sure to compare rates on your own which is the best way to ensure you secure the most affordable rate for you.


Find the cheapest rates by comparing quotes today


Cheapest Quotes for Drivers with Multiple Accidents

Finding affordable car insurance when you have multiple accidents on your driving record may be difficult but it’s not impossible. Our research uncovered five insurance companies that are willing to take a bet on you while keeping your insurance rates more reasonable.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Acceptance $168
Infinity $182
Gainsco $198
Direct Auto $212
Esurance $242

Acceptance Insurance offers an average rate of $168/mo for auto insurance if you have multiple accidents on your record. You see rates climb significantly higher with Infinity at $182/mo. Gainsco ($198/mo) and Direct Auto ($212/mo) offer similar rates before you see another steep climb to $242/mo with Esurance.

To avoid overpaying for car insurance in Florida, shop around for car insurance often. Although it’ll take a few years for the accidents to drop off your record, you can still enjoy affordable car insurance while you wait.

The Cheapest Florida State Minimum Insurance

Before you register a vehicle in Florida, you must show proof that you’ve obtained the state’s minimum liability coverage.

In Florida, you need at least $10,000 in Personal Injury Protection (PIP). PIP covers 80 percent of all necessary and reasonable medical expenses resulting from an injury. You’ll also be required to have at least $10,000 in Property Damage Liability (PDL). As the name implies, PDL coverage pays for damage to another person’s property due to an accident caused by you or someone else driving your vehicle.

We’ve identified nine companies that offer the cheapest rates for Florida’s minimum coverage requirements.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Dairyland $75
Infinity $86
Assurance America $87
Direct Auto $98
Gainsco $101
Acceptance $120
Answer Financial $151
Esurance $158
Liberty Mutual $165

Dairyland is hands down the most affordable option at only $75 per month. Followed closely by Infinity ($86/mo.), Assurance America ($87/mo.), Direct Auto ($98/mo.), Gainsco ($101/mo.), Acceptance ($120/mo.), Answer Financial ($151/mo.), Esurance ($158/mo.), and Liberty Mutual ($165/mo.).

These options are just a starting point, but it’s always a great idea to do some comparison shopping to find the most budget-friendly auto insurance for you.


Unlock your cheapest rates in minutes


The Best Rates for Full Coverage in Florida

There’s no question that full coverage car insurance provides peace of mind. Full coverage auto insurance includes two things that liability-only policies do not, collision and comprehensive coverage. Collision insurance coverage pays a portion of the cost to repair your vehicle if you’re involved in an accident while comprehensive insurance coverage pays for damage to your car caused by incidents “other than collisions,” like natural disasters, fire, vandalism, theft, broken windshields, or fallen objects such as trees.

Below, we’ve listed seven of the cheapest companies providing full coverage car insurance in Florida. Although full coverage car insurance is not required to register a vehicle in Florida, it is a great way to provide physical protection for your car.

Insurance Company Monthly Premium
Assurance America $145
Infinity $151
DirectGeneral $154
Gainsco $161
Esurance $208
Answer Financial $222
Acceptance $227

Take a look at Assurance America. A full-coverage policy will set you back $145 every month. Coming in at $151 per month is Infinity, followed by Direct Auto ($154/mo), Gainsco ($161/mo), Esurance ($208/mo), Answer Financial ($222/mo), and we have Acceptance with the highest rates at $227 monthly.

When looking at the rates for state minimum and full coverage insurance, you see that drivers who choose state minimum coverage pay less overall. For example, choosing state minimum coverage with Assurance America will  have you paying $87/mo in liability insurance. However, you will pay $145/mo for full coverage. That $58 difference is certainly nothing to sneeze at. Over the course of a year, you’ll pay almost $700 more in car insurance! 

The Best Car Insurance Companies in Florida

J.D. Power, a leader in automotive research, collected consumer reviews on Florida’s best-rated car insurance companies. Below, we’ve listed the top 10 on their list. These scores are based on a 1,000 point scale.

  • Allstate – 851
  • GEICO – 846
  • Automobile Club Group – 839
  • Liberty Mutual – 837
  • Region Average – 836
  • Progressive – 834
  • Esurance – 830
  • State Farm – 826
  • The Hartford – 826
  • Auto-Owners Insurance – 821

Allstate tops the list with 851 points. GEICO (846 points), Automobile Club Group (839 points) and Liberty Mutual (837 points) all follow closely behind. The score was based on a combination of interaction, price, policy offerings, the billing process, and policy information and claims.


Compare rates from Florida’s best insurance companies


The Best Car Insurance Discounts in Florida

Woman researching car insurance discounts

Saving money on your car in Florida insurance can add up and knowing which discounts are available to you may not always be obvious. But we’re pulling back the veil and revealing how you can put a dent in your auto insurance premiums.

  • Vehicle Equipment Discounts. Auto insurers reward drivers who own vehicles equipped with modern safety features like airbags, anti-lock brakes, anti-theft systems, and daytime running lamps.
  • Customer Loyalty Discounts. Insurers are always looking for ways to provide additional services to their customers for added savings. Multi-vehicle discounts are perfect if you plan to insure more than one vehicle under the same policy. Multi-policy discounts will save you money when you bundle your homeowner and auto policies together.
  • Employer Affiliation Discounts. Current or former military members, federal government employees, first responders, and front-line workers can receive an additional discount on your auto insurance premium.
  • Driver Affiliation Discounts. Are you a member of an alumni association, college or university, fraternity, sorority, recreational, business or professional organization? If you answered yes, ask your auto insurer if you qualify for additional discounts based on your affiliation.
  • Accident-Free Driving Discounts. Your good driving history can lead to cheaper auto insurance. If you’ve been accident-free for at least five years, you may qualify for even more savings on your insurance.
  • Driver Education Discounts. Did you know that brushing up on your driving skills can save you money? Taking a defensive driving course or driver’s education course may earn a discount on your auto policy.

The Cheapest FL Cities for Car Insurance

We analyzed thousands of car insurance quotes in over 100 Florida cities to help give you an idea of what you might pay.

Check out the table below to find average rates in cities all across The Sunshine State:

City Average Monthly Car Insurance Premium
Altamonte Springs $114
Apopka $120
Auburndale $128
Boca Raton $143
Boynton Beach $164
Bradenton $107
Brandon $147
Brooksville $118
Cape Coral $104
Casselberry $112
Clearwater $123
Clermont $110
Cocoa $108
Coral Springs $144
Davenport $97
Daytona Beach $91
Deerfield Beach $147
Deland $102
Delray Beach $158
Deltona $99
Eustis $96
Fort Lauderdale $146
Fort Myers $115
Fort Pierce $108
Fort Walton Beach $93
Gainesville $85
Hallandale $123
Hialeah $167
Holiday $128
Hollywood $153
Homestead $160
Hudson $126
Jacksonville $117
Jupiter $107
Kissimmee $121
Lake City $89
Lake Wales $102
Lake Worth $189
Lakeland $114
Land O Lakes $123
Largo $110
Leesburg $97
Lehigh Acres $138
Longwood $109
Lutz $145
Melbourne $98
Miami $152
Miami Beach $119
Miami Gardens $153
Middleburg $114
Milton $94
Naples $106
New Port Richey $132
North Fort Myers $99
North Miami Beach $109
North Port $94
Ocala $95
Ocoee $134
Opa Locka $154
Orange Park $108
Orlando $127
Ormond Beach $86
Oviedo $109
Palm Bay $98
Palm Beach Gardens $120
Palm Coast $89
Palm Harbor $145
Panama City $86
Pensacola $101
Pinellas Park $150
Plant City $115
Pompano Beach $149
Port Charlotte $100
Port Orange $91
Port Richey $119
Port St. Lucie $120
Punta Gorda $86
Riverview $129
St. Augustine $85
St. Cloud $111
St. Petersburg $123
Sanford $103
Sarasota $98
Sebring $86
Spring Hill $119
Stuart $107
Tallahassee $88
Tampa $172
Titusville $99
Valrico $123
Venice $89
Vero Beach $97
Wellington $143
Wesley Chapel $121
West Palm Beach $176
Winter Garden $103
Winter Haven $128
Winter Park $115
Winter Springs $104
Zephyrhills $106

Click on the name of each city in the table above to find detailed breakdowns of all the factors that go into calculating your monthly premium. Here, you’ll find the information you need on how factors like your driving record, age, gendervehicle make and model, and more will affect how much you pay for car insurance in each locality.

And if you want to jump right in and see how much you’ll pay, simply enter your ZIP code below and find your best rate in minutes!


Compare cheap rates in Florida for free!


Florida Car Insurance Requirements, Laws, and Penalties

Florida is known for having the lowest state minimum requirements for car insurance in the U.S. To legally drive in Florida, you must hold coverage for:

Bodily injury liability — the part of your insurance policy that pays for injuries sustained by passengers in your car or in a vehicle you hit — is not required in Florida (unless you have been in a crash or have a conviction for certain offenses). It’s a wise idea to buy it, however, and most Florida drivers do.

What happens if you don’t have insurance in Florida?

Florida has the nation’s highest percentage of uninsured drivers: 26.7% of drivers have no insurance! That’s bad news. If you’re caught driving without insurance in Florida, the penalties may include the suspension of your registration and license plates for up to three years (or until proof of insurance is provided), plus a reinstatement fee of $150 to $500.

Florida Vehicle Registration Fees and Other Costs

If you’re in the market for a new or used car, you’ll need to budget for more than just the vehicle’s sticker price. You’ll be on the hook for basic DMV fees like title, license plate, and registration no matter where and how you purchase your new car, truck, or SUV, as well as buying a new car insurance policy for your car.

But some buyers will also be responsible for additional fees such as sales tax, documentation fees, personal property tax, emissions and inspection fees, hybrid and electric vehicle fees, lien recording fees, and a slew of other costs.

Check out Compare.com’s comprehensive vehicle costs breakdown to make sure you account for all the added costs you might be on the hook for when buying a car in Florida.

Florida Car Insurance FAQs

What car insurance is required in Florida?

To register a vehicle in Florida, you must show proof of the following insurance:

  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP). Covers 80% of all necessary and reasonable medical expenses up to $10,000 resulting from a covered injury, no matter who caused the crash.
  • Property Damage Liability (PDL). Coverage pays for damage to another person’s property caused by you or someone else driving your insured vehicle.

How much is car insurance in Florida?

Based on the amount of coverage you need and other factors like age, gender and credit score, the cost of car insurance in the Sunshine State can vary widely. However, for most drivers the average cost of car insurance in Florida is $135/mo.

What happens if you drive without insurance in Florida?

If you’re caught driving without insurance in Florida, it could lead to suspension of your driver’s license, license plate, and registration for up to 3 years. You may also incur fines, penalties, and reinstate fees of up to $500. Florida determines your costs based on the number of times you’re caught driving without insurance.

Does Florida require full coverage car insurance?

No, you are not required to have full coverage car insurance. However, all registered vehicles registered in Florida must obtain their minimum liability coverage requirements.


 

Methodology

All data referenced in this article comes from a combination of proprietary data — which is aggregated from millions of real customer quotes through Compare.com — and additional data gathered in collaboration with Quadrant.