How to Find the Best Car Insurance Companies in 2023

Are you on the hunt for the best car insurance company? Use Compare.com’s industry-leading price comparison tool to find all top auto insurance companies based on your specific needs.

Home Auto Insurance Best Car Insurance Companies

Why You Can Trust Compare.com

At Compare.com, it’s our mission to find simple ways to help our customers save money on the things they need. While we partner with some of the companies and brands we talk about in our articles, all of our content is written and reviewed by our independent editorial team and never influenced by our partnerships. Learn about how we make money, review our editorial standards, and reference our data methodology to learn more about why you can trust Compare.com.

Written by Quiana Darden

Edited by Nick Versaw

Updated March 13, 2023

How to Find the Best Car Insurance

You own a vehicle and know that to protect it, you need quality auto insurance. You’re not just looking for good – you want the best car insurance on the market. But, the best is subjective. Finding the right company might vary based on your age, driving record, military status or even your gender. So, how do you find the best car insurance company for you?

We’ve compiled a list of the top insurance options specific to you.

Best Car Insurance Companies Based on Your Age

Did you know your car insurance rates can vary based on how old you are? Teenage drivers tend to have the highest premiums because they lack experience, which makes them more likely to be involved in collisions. Rates drop slightly once you age out of your teenage years, but will remain high until you reach your 25th birthday. You might see another change in rates once you turn 65 years old. That’s when insurance companies expect your age to again impact your driving habits.

These are the best car insurance companies based on your age.

Best for Teen Drivers

Since teen drivers lack much experience behind the wheel, you definitely want them to have the best insurance coverage available. Pair that with their higher than average rates and finding quality coverage within your budget can be a challenge. Thankfully, we have a list of great insurers that make your insuring a teen driver a great experience.

Best for 18 Year Old Drivers

At 18 years old, you’re still a high risk driver. That’s why you want to find the best insurance coverage that caters to your stage in life and insurance needs. We researched insurers that offer the quality coverage you need.

Best for Drivers Under 25 Years Old

Finding quality car insurance as a young driver under 25 years old can be tricky, but it’s not impossible. At this age you’re facing higher rates than you would after your 25th birthday, so, while price is a major factor, you want to consider other aspects of the company in making your decision. When finding the best auto insurance company you can look at what’s important to you such as available discounts, customer service, coverage options and app technology.

Best for 50 Year Old Drivers

At 50 years old, you’re familiar with how to find car insurance, but securing the best coverage might still leave you with a few questions. We’ve compiled a list of the best insurers that serve you during this stage in life.

Best Car Insurance Companies Based on Your Gender

In most states, auto insurance companies use your gender as a factor when determining your insurance premium. That’s because data shows men are more likely to engage in risky driving behavior than women. Therefore, to take on that added risk, insurance companies charge higher rates. If you live in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina or Pennsylvania, insurers are prohibited from factoring in gender when setting premiums.

These are the best car insurance companies based on your gender.

Best Car Insurance Companies for Women

There are more female drivers on the road now than ever before. So women it’s important for women to find quality auto insurance to protect their vehicle and finances. We’ve put together a list of top auto insurance companies for female drivers along with more info on how your gender impacts your auto insurance premiums.

Best Car Insurance Companies Based on Your Marital Status

When on the hunt for the best auto insurance company, be sure to keep your marital status in mind. Not only can your insurance premium change if you’re married, single or divorced, but so can your process of finding the best insurer.

Best Car Insurance Companies for Married Drivers

When you get married you can decide to combine your auto insurance policy with your spouse or maintain separate plans. Depending on your driving record and personal preference, there are pros and cons both ways. We’ve compiled a list of the best auto insurers for married drivers.

Best Car Insurance Companies Based on Your Driving Record

If you have a perfect driving record, it’s easy to find quality auto insurance with just about any company. However, if you have a few marks on your driving history – whether it’s an accident, ticket or DUI – finding quality coverage can get trickier. Thankfully, there are options for everyone. Some auto insurance companies specialize in working with high risk drivers or offer programs that still allow you to have affordable coverage.

Here are the best car insurance companies based on your driving record.

Best Car Insurance Companies for Drivers With an Accident on Their Record

If you have an accident on your record, it can be more challenging (and costly) to get the best auto insurance. That’s because insurers might consider you a high-risk driver. It’s important to find quality coverage no matter your driving history, so check out this list of top auto insurance companies for drivers with an accident on their record.

Best Car Insurance Companies for Drivers With a DUI

Being convicted of driving under the influence adds several hurdles to getting quality auto insurance. Many insurers will drop your coverage when it’s time to renew or significantly increase your premiums.

How Do I Find the Best Car Insurance Company?

With hundreds of car insurance providers offering coverage in 51 insurance districts in the U.S., it can be a difficult task to find the best car insurance company for you and your specific insurance needs. Not to worry, we have some great tips on how to sift through all those car insurance companies.

When it comes to finding the right coverage, everyone’s needs differ. The best car insurance company for one person may not always a good car insurance company for the next. This is why it’s important to do your research before making your final choice. We have put together a few tips to help get you started on finding the insurer that’s right for you.

1. Check Your State’s Insurance Department Website

Each state in the U.S. has an insurance department which is responsible for regulating auto insurers within that state. Their website can be a valuable resource for information such as complaint filings and licensing information. Additionally, many state insurance department websites make public car insurance companies’ insurance rate filings. This means you can see how often each insurance provider requests to raise its rates, as well as how often those requests are granted.

2. Check the Insurance Company’s Financial Rating

Car insurance providers are financial institutions and as such, it’s important to know their rating to understand how secure the company is (and that it’s not overextending itself, or insuring more than it can afford to pay). Two of the top financial rating groups are:

Standard & Poor’s
- More commonly known as S&P
A.M. Best
- A.M. Best is particularly important as they specifically rate insurance companies.

3. Research Online Customer Reviews of Insurers

While the ratings of insurance and financial analysts are very important, when it comes to figuring out whether or not you’ll be happy with a certain car insurance company, you need to see what their customers think of them. Look for specific information, such as the ease of filing an insurance claim, the length of time it takes the company to settle an insurance claim and how easy it is to reach an agent or customer service professional.

Customer service is a great measure for determining the best car insurance company for you.

4. Compare Car Insurance Rates

It’s usually not a good idea to pick the first car insurance company you find. Typically, you’ll want to compare car insurance rates from at least 3-4 companies before making your final selection. Take the time to review both large insurers and smaller car insurers.

If you enjoy saving time, Compare.com can compare multiple car insurance quotes from some of the best insurance brands instantly. You enter your information only once and can compare quotes side by side to find the best price.

By taking these steps to find the best car insurance company for your situation, you’ll know exactly what you’re getting and can rest assured that you’ll be happy with the service you receive from your chosen auto insurance company.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose a car insurance company?

The process of finding a quality car insurance company will depend on what you need and want from an insurer. When you start your search the first thing you should do is write a list of the things you’re seeking from an auto insurance company. Maybe you want several online customer service options or perhaps you’re seeking certain discounts. Once you know what you’re looking for, it’ll be easier to narrow down your options. Comparing auto insurance quotes and company ratings can also help you make your decision.

How can I find the best price on car insurance?

The best way to find a low rate on auto insurance is to get quotes from different companies. You can use our auto insurance comparison calculator to compare rates from 65+ top insurers in minutes.

Which company has the highest customer satisfaction rating?

According to the J.D. Power 2022 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, these auto insurance companies have the highest satisfaction ratings in these geographic regions.

California: Wawanesa
Central: Shelter
Florida: The Hartford
Mid-Atlantic: Erie Insurance
New England: Amica Mutual
New York: New York Central Mutual
North Central: Erie Insurance
Northwest: The Hartford
Southeast: Farm Bureau Insurance – Tennessee
Southwest: State Farm
Texas: Texas Farm Bureau

Quiana Darden Lead Insurance Editor

Quiana Darden is a member of Compare.com’s editorial team. She has over 4 years of experience writing in the auto insurance, business insurance and personal finance niche. Her work has been featured in countless publications and she has crafted content for companies in a numerous, including Elephant Insurance and other similar organizations. Quiana graduated with honors from Virginia Commonwealth University and obtained her Master’s Degree from Old Dominion University.

About Compare.com

Compare.com’s #1 goal is to save you money. We publish resources that are based on hard-hitting data and years of industry experience to help you make more informed decisions with your wallet.

All of Compare.com’s content is written and reviewed for accuracy by a team of experienced writers and editors who are experts on the topics they cover.
None of Compare.com’s content is ever influenced by the companies and brands we partner with.
Compare.com’s editorial team operates independently of any of the company’s partnership or business development interests. We publish unbiased information strictly for the benefit of our readers.
All of the content you see on Compare.com is based on comprehensive analysis and all data is gathered and vetted from trustworthy sources.

Learn more about us, our team, and what makes us tick.