Fayetteville, NY Car Insurance

Fayetteville drivers pay, on average, around $168 a month for their car insurance. For information on policy rates, coverage, and more check out our guide below.
What should residents of Fayetteville expect to pay for their car insurance? How do rates in Fayetteville measure up compared to neighboring areas, including New York as a whole? Discover the factors that go into calculating the average cost in our writeups and charts below:  

How much is car insurance in Fayetteville?

Area Average Monthly Car Insurance Premium
Fayetteville$168
NY$198
United States$80

According to the chart above, the average cost of auto insurance in New York is about $30 a month more expensive than it is in Fayetteville.

On the flip side, residents of Fayetteville might expect to pay higher rates for coverage than the rest of the country. The average monthly payment in Fayetteville is about $88 more expensive than the rate for the rest of the U.S.

Keep in mind that while these are the average car insurance rates for Fayetteville, it isn't guaranteed that it's what you'll pay. There are numerous factors taken into consideration by insurance companies when deciding the rate you'll pay for coverage. Things like gender, vehicle make and model, driving record, age and, in some areas, credit score can all affect the bill you'll see each month.

We've done the heavy lifting for you and broken down the average rate for Fayetteville so that you can get a more accurate idea of what you might pay. And if you're not sure if you're getting the cheapest rate for your area, simply enter your ZIP Code below and find out!

See what you'll pay in just minutes

Average Car Insurance Rates by Age

Age Range Average Premium
Under 18Not Enough Data
18-24$182
25-34Not Enough Data
35-44Not Enough Data
45-54Not Enough Data
55-64$40
65+$62

Generally speaking, the older you are, the more experience you have driving, right? When it comes to car insurance bills, that experience pays off. According to the table above, you can see that 18-24-year-olds pay $120 more than drivers 65 and older.

You can expect to see your monthly premium drop about once a decade or so. Drivers in Fayetteville may see their rates rise again once they hit retirement age.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Gender

Gender Average
Male$102
Female$176

Although women typically pay less than men do for auto insurance, this is not the case in Fayetteville, where female drivers pay around $176 per month while male drivers pay about $102.

Average Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Infractions Average Monthly Premium
1 AccidentNot Enough Data
Multiple AccidentsNot Enough Data
1 TicketNot Enough Data
Multiple TicketsNot Enough Data

One of the biggest factors in determining your car insurance rates is your driving record. Drivers with clean records will pay significantly lower rates than those with accidents or violations.

Wherever you live, accidents, tickets, and other driving infractions can cost you some serious cash. In order to minimize your monthly rate, practice safe driving habits and keep your record clean.

Average Insurance Rates by Vehicle

Vehicle Age Average Monthly Premium
Less Than 1 YearNot Enough Data
2-3 YearsNot Enough Data
4-5 YearsNot Enough Data
6-7 Years$43
8-10 YearsNot Enough Data
11-14 Years$62
15 Years or Older$182

In addition to vehicle type, you can also expect to see slightly different rates based on your vehicle's age. Generally, newer vehicles are going to be the most expensive to insure. Once your car is around 5 years old, however, you may see your bill start to shrink a bit. In Fayetteville, vehicles fifteen years and older and eleven-to-fourteen years old are the most expensive to insure.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Relationship Status

Relationship Average Monthly Premium
Single (never married)$173
Married$50
Divorced$41

Generally speaking, car insurance is slightly cheaper for married policyholders. This usually boils down to owners having multiple vehicles on the same policy, something that will often get you a discount.

The difference in rates based on relationship status in Fayetteville can be as much as $123 a month, so it's worth keeping that in mind.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Housing Situation

Housing Status Average Monthly Premium
Own$50
Rent$170
Live with parents$169

Another factor that comes into play is your housing situation. Those who own their own home in Fayetteville can expect to pay around $120 a month less than those who rent. But if you live with your parents, you can expect to pay a lot more.

If you bundle your home or rental insurance and auto insurance policies, you can oftentimes reduce your average costs, depending on your insurance company.

Car Insurance Companies in Fayetteville, NY

Recent trends in car insurance for Fayetteville drivers

The average rates for car insurance are constantly changing, so it's a good idea to know the recent trends in your area when choosing your car insurance policy.

The rates for car insurance in Fayetteville dropped from 2017-2018, before steadying out in 2020. They finished down in 2021, at $58 per month

How does Fayetteville compare to neighboring areas?

Why are car insurance rates in Fayetteville different from other areas?

When considering how much to charge for an insurance policy, car insurance companies will evaluate several factors. A few of these factors affecting your personal policy have already been mentioned, but others are based around where you live and drive. These include things like:

  • Number of car accidents
  • Amount of drivers in the region
  • Off-street parking access
  • Crime levels
  • Regional regulations

You'll be hard pressed to change any of these factors yourself, but they're worth considering when thinking about the purchase of a new policy or a move. Get started with a guide like this to get familiar with the average rates of your area.

How can I find the cheapest car insurance in Fayetteville?

In the end, the only way to know exactly what your rate will be is to request a quote from a car insurance company.

But hold on! Compare.com does all of that work for you. Enter your ZIP below, answer a few questions, and you'll be comparing the cheapest quotes from the many car insurance companies providing auto coverage in Fayetteville.

Compare the cheapest quotes from dozens of insurance companies

Fayetteville Insurance FAQs

What factors affect car insurance quotes in Fayetteville?

The factors that car insurance companies take into account when calculating your monthly cost include things you can't control like your gender and age, but also factors like your vehicle's year, make and model, plus your address, credit score, marital status, and driving record.

Why is the cost of car insurance in Fayetteville different from other neighboring cities?

Auto insurance companies consider regional factors, such as local laws, parking situations, and crime rates into account when calculating the monthly rate for coverage. Since these can all vary from city to city the rates you may see can differ from neighboring areas.

Which car insurance company will offer me the cheapest rate in Fayetteville?

Since the factors that car insurance companies take into consideration when calculating the rate you might pay differ from person to person, there is no one insurance company that will offer the cheapest rate to everybody. Things like your driving record, the number of drivers on the policy, and vehicle make and model, plus a number of others, are all taken into account. Because of this, it's a good idea to use sites like Compare.com to compare multiple quotes at once.

Do I need to change my insurance if I move to Fayetteville?

Any major life event, whether it be moving to a new area, finding a new job, getting married, or any other notable event always presents a good opportunity to re-evaluate your current insurance policy. Regardless of your previous rate, there may be cheaper options in your new location, so it's a good idea to use services like Compare.com to compare quotes from dozens of companies side-by-side.

Do I need to wait for my policy to expire to switch to a different car insurance company?

No. Regardless of how much time is left on your current policy, you can switch companies at any time. So, whether you're considering moving to Fayetteville or just curious if you're getting the best rates, why not take 10 minutes and see if Compare.com can save you some extra cash?

Find your best rate in just a few minutes