Fayetteville, NY Car Insurance

On average, Fayetteville drivers pay around $168 a month for their car insurance. Learn more in our handy guide below.
What should residents of Fayetteville expect to pay for their car insurance? How does Fayetteville compare to the surrounding area and the rest of New York? You can see the cost breakdowns and contributing factors in the charts and writeups below:  

How much is car insurance in Fayetteville?

Area Average Monthly Car Insurance Premium
Fayetteville$168
NY$199
United States$81

As you can see in the chart above, it is around $31 a month cheaper to insure your vehicle in Fayetteville than it is in the rest of New York.

Drivers relocating the Fayetteville should take note of the differences in average rates. It's about $87 more for coverage in Fayetteville than in the rest of the U.S.

These may be the average auto insurance rates for Fayetteville, but that doesn't mean it's exactly what you'll pay. The monthly rate that insurance companies end up charging you is determined by a variety of factors. The final dollar amount you'll be asked to pay each month is calculated off of your age, gender, vehicle make and model, driving record, and even your credit score depending on the circumstances.

Don't sweat it however, we've broken down average rates for Fayetteville residents based on several different factors so that you can get a more accurate idea of your policy's monthly premium. And if you're not sure if you're getting the cheapest rate, simply enter your ZIP below and find out in just minutes!

See what you'll pay in just minutes

Average Car Insurance Rates by Age

Age Range Average Premium
Under 18Not Enough Data
18-24$182
25-34Not Enough Data
35-44Not Enough Data
45-54$50
55-64$40
65+$62

It's pretty safe to assume that the older you are, the more experience you have as a driver. That experience pays off when it comes to auto insurance. As you can see, 18-24-year-olds pay two times as much as someone who is retirement aged.

You can expect to see your monthly premium drop every 10 years or so. Drivers in Fayetteville may see their rates start to rise again once they hit retirement.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Gender

Gender Average
Male$102
Female$176

While women typically pay less than men do for auto insurance, Fayetteville bucks this trend. Female drivers typically pay around $74 more a month for auto insurance coverage than their male counterparts.

Average Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Infractions Average Monthly Premium
1 AccidentNot Enough Data
Multiple AccidentsNot Enough Data
1 TicketNot Enough Data
Multiple TicketsNot Enough Data

Rates can vary wildly depending on your driving record. Drivers with clean records will pay lower rates than those with accidents or violations.

Accidents, tickets, and other driving infractions can cost you some serious cash. That's why it's important to drive safely and keep your record clean so you can keep your rates as low as possible.

Average Insurance Rates by Vehicle

Vehicle Age Average Monthly Premium
Less Than 1 YearNot Enough Data
2-3 YearsNot Enough Data
4-5 YearsNot Enough Data
6-7 Years$43
8-10 YearsNot Enough Data
11-14 Years$62
15 Years or Older$182

In addition to vehicle type, you can also expect to see slightly different rates depending on the age of your vehicle. Generally, newer vehicles are going to be the most expensive to insure. However, once your car is around 5 years old, you may start to see your monthly premium drop back down. The most expensive vehicles to insure in Fayetteville are vehicles fifteen years and older and eleven-to-fourteen years old.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Relationship Status

Relationship Average Monthly Premium
Single (never married)$173
Married$50
Divorced$41

More often than not, people who are married will pay slightly less to insure their car. This oftentimes is a result of owning multiple vehicles that are on the same policy, something that will often get you a discount.

In Fayetteville, the difference in rates based on relationship status can be as much as $123 a month.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Housing Situation

Housing Status Average Monthly Premium
Own$50
Rent$170
Live with parents$169

Another factor taken into consideration is your living situation. If you rent your home or apartment in Fayetteville, expect to pay around $120 a month more than if you own property. But those who live at home with their parents can expect to pay significantly more.

Bundling your home or rental insurance with your auto insurance can oftentimes reduce your average costs, depending on your insurance company.

Car Insurance Companies in Fayetteville, NY

Recent trends in car insurance for Fayetteville drivers

Since car insurance rates are constantly changing, it's a good idea to know the local trends in your area before selecting an auto insurance policy.

The cost of auto insurance coverage in Fayetteville decreased from 2017-2018, before leveling out in 2020. Rates finished down in 2021, at $58 per month

How does Fayetteville compare to neighboring areas?

Why are car insurance rates in Fayetteville different from other areas?

There are several factors car insurance companies take into consideration when deciding how much to charge for coverage. While we already talked about the ones that affect your personal policy, others are based around where you call home. These include things like:

  • Off-street parking availability
  • Number of car accidents
  • Crime levels
  • Amount of drivers in the area
  • Community regulations

You'll be hard pressed to change any of these factors yourself, but they're worth considering when thinking about the purchase of a new policy or a move. With the knowledge that different towns and cities will all have different rates, guides like these can be a good way to get a lay of the land of your particular neighborhood.

How can I find the cheapest car insurance in Fayetteville?

Arming yourself with information about the average costs for drivers in your area will better prepare you for the real deal. The only way to know for sure what your rate will be is by asking for a quote from car insurance companies.

Good news! Compare.com does all of that work for you. Just type in your ZIP Code below, answer a few questions about your driving profile, and you'll be comparing the cheapest quotes from several of the car insurance companies offering auto coverage in Fayetteville.

Compare the cheapest quotes from dozens of insurance companies

Fayetteville Insurance FAQs

What factors affect car insurance quotes in Fayetteville?

Car insurance companies calculate quotes based on a wide array of factors. These include things like your age and gender, but also factors like your vehicle's year, make and model, as well as your driving record, credit score, marital status, and address.

Why is the cost of car insurance in Fayetteville different from other neighboring cities?

Auto insurance companies consider regional factors, such as parking situations, crime rates, and local laws into account when calculating the monthly rate for coverage. Since these can all vary from city to city the rates you may see can differ from neighboring areas.

Which car insurance company will offer me the cheapest rate in Fayetteville?

No one insurance company is guaranteed to offer the cheapest rate across the board. Since companies base their rates on factors that differ from person to person, such as driving record, number of drivers on the policy, vehicle make and model, and many more, it's a good idea to use sites like Compare.com to compare multiple quotes at once.

Do I need to change my insurance if I move to Fayetteville?

Any major life event, whether it be moving to a new area, finding a new job, getting married, or any other notable event always presents a good opportunity to re-evaluate your current insurance policy. Regardless of your previous rate, there may be cheaper options in your new location, so it's a good idea to use services like Compare.com to compare quotes from dozens of companies side-by-side.

Do I need to wait for my policy to expire to switch to a different car insurance company?

No. You can switch companies at any time, regardless of how long is left on your current policy. So, if you've recently moved to Fayetteville or it's been a while since you last compared car insurance rates, you may want to take 10 minutes and see if Compare.com can save you money.

Find your best rate in just a few minutes