Staten Island, NY Car Insurance

The average monthly cost for car insurance in Staten Island is about $187. Check out our guide below to find out how much you'll pay.
Are rates in Staten Island higher or lower than those in neighboring areas? How do they compare to the rest of New York? What can Staten Island residents expect to pay for their car insurance? See what factors contribute to determining the average cost in our detailed charts and breakdowns below:  

How much is car insurance in Staten Island?

Area Average Monthly Car Insurance Premium
Staten Island$187
NY$199
United States$81

Compared to the rest of the New York, coverage in Staten Island is about $12 a month cheaper.

On the other hand, Staten Island residents will likely pay higher rates to insure their vehicle than in the rest of the country. It's around $106 more expensive to insure your vehicle in Staten Island compared to the average rate for the rest of the U.S.

While these are the average car insurance rates for Staten Island, you could end up paying something different. There are a number of factors that determine how much insurance companies might charge you to insure your vehicle. Things like age, gender, vehicle make and model, driving record and, in some areas, credit score can all get factored into calculating the amount you'll be asked to pay each month.

We've done the heavy lifting for you and broken down the average rate for Staten Island so that you can get a more accurate idea of what you might pay. If you think you might be overpaying for insurance in your area, enter your ZIP below and find out!

See what you'll pay in just minutes

Average Car Insurance Rates by Age

Age Range Average Premium
Under 18Not Enough Data
18-24$305
25-34$172
35-44$158
45-54$169
55-64$139
65+$163

It's pretty safe to assume that the older you are, the longer you've been driving, right? When it comes to auto insurance rates, that experience can help put some change back into your pocket. According to the table above, you can see that 18-24-year-olds pay a lot more than someone who is at retirement age.

Every ten years or so you can expect to see a decline in your monthly premium. That said, once you hit retirement, your rates may climb back up in Staten Island.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Gender

Gender Average
Male$189
Female$184

In general, female drivers pay less for car insurance than their male counterparts. The difference in average rates in Staten Island totals about $5 a month. As you can see in the table above, female drivers in the area typically pay $184 on average, while female drivers typically pay $189 each month.

Average Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Record

Infractions Average Monthly Premium
1 Accident$221
Multiple Accidents$261
1 Ticket$199
Multiple Tickets$238

Your rates can change quite drastically depending on your driving record. Those with clean records will see the most affordable rates, whereas even a single accident or infraction can cost you. In Staten Island, a driving record with one accident will usually get you a rate around $221 a month. Likewise, drivers with one ticket on their record will be looking at an average rate of around $199.

Regardless of where you live, accidents, tickets, and other driving infractions can drive your monthly bill way up. So, if cheap car insurance is something you're after, drive safely and keep a clean record.

Average Insurance Rates by Vehicle

Vehicle Age Average Monthly Premium
Less Than 1 Year$182
2-3 Years$202
4-5 Years$193
6-7 Years$181
8-10 Years$189
11-14 Years$185
15 Years or Older$182

The cheapest vehicles to insure in Staten Island are usually trucks and vans, with each type typically costing about $173 per month.

Cars and SUVs, on the other hand, cost about the same to insure, around $188 per month.

In addition to vehicle type, you can also expect to see slightly different rates depending on the age of your vehicle. Newer vehicles are generally going to be the most expensive to insure. However, your rates may start to drop back down once your car is a few years old. In Staten Island, the most expensive vehicles to insure are vehicles four-to-five years old.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Relationship Status

Relationship Average Monthly Premium
Single (never married)$193
Married$151
Divorced$166
Widowed$186

Generally, those who have settled down into marriage will pay slightly less for car insurance. This usually boils down to owners having multiple vehicles on the same policy, something that will often get you a discount.

According to the table above, the difference in rates based on relationship status in Staten Island can be as much as $42 a month, so it's worth taking into consideration.

Average Car Insurance Rates by Housing Situation

Housing Status Average Monthly Premium
Own$174
Rent$190
Live with parents$325

Another factor that comes into play is your living accommodations. In Staten Island, homeowners can expect to pay around $16 a month less than those who rent. Those who live with their parents, however, can expect to pay a good deal more than their counterparts who rent or own.

Bundling your home or rental insurance and auto insurance policies can oftentimes reduce your overall costs, depending on your insurance company.

Car Insurance Companies in Staten Island, NY

Recent trends in car insurance for Staten Island drivers

The average rates for car insurance are constantly changing, so it's a good idea to know the recent trends in your area before shopping for coverage.

In Staten Island, auto insurance rates rose from 2017-2018, when they reached a low of $113. This shifted in 2019, when car insurance rates began to increase. They hit a high of $230 in 2021, and finished down in 2022, at $153 per month.

How does Staten Island compare to neighboring areas?

Why are car insurance rates in Staten Island different from other areas?

There are several factors car insurance companies will consider when deciding how much to charge for a monthly rate. A few of these factors affecting your personal policy have already been mentioned, but others are based around your home address. These include things like:

  • Road Safety (how many accidents each locality has)
  • Amount of drivers
  • Off-street parking access
  • Community laws
  • Crime levels

Having an awareness of these factors is critical when thinking about buying a new policy or potentially moving to a new home. Get started with a guide like this to get familiar with the average rates of your area.

How can I find the cheapest car insurance in Staten Island?

While getting familiar with what the average costs are for drivers like you can be helpful as you get an idea of what you might pay, the only way to know exactly what your rate will be is by requesting a quote from car insurance companies.

Fortunately, Compare.com does all of that work for you. Put in your ZIP Code below, answer a few questions related to the factors we outlined above, and you'll be comparing the cheapest quotes from many of the car insurance companies providing plans in Staten Island.

Compare the cheapest quotes from dozens of insurance companies

Staten Island Insurance FAQs

What factors affect car insurance quotes in Staten Island?

Car insurance companies calculate quotes based on a wide array of factors. These include things you can't control like your age and gender but also factors like your vehicle's year, make and model, plus your driving record, credit score, marital status, and address.

Why is the cost of car insurance in Staten Island different from other neighboring cities?

Car insurance companies take local factors into consideration when determining how much to charge for coverage. Things like crime rates, local laws, and parking situations -- which can vary from city to city -- can significantly affect your rate.

Which car insurance company will offer me the cheapest rate in Staten Island?

Since the factors that go into calculating your monthly payment vary from person to person, there isn't one company that will always offer the cheapest rate to everybody. You can be confident that you're receiving the best price possible however, by using sites like Compare.com to compare multiple quotes at once.

Do I need to change my insurance if I move to Staten Island?

Any time you experience a major life event, whether it's moving to a new area, getting married, finding a new job, or other notable events, it's always a good idea to re-evaluate your current insurance. Certain companies offer cheaper insurance in certain cities, so even if you were getting the cheapest rate at your old address, it doesn't mean it'll still be the cheapest at your new home. That's why it's always good to use services like Compare.com to compare quotes from dozens of companies side-by-side.

Do I need to wait for my policy to expire to switch to a different car insurance company?

No, you can switch companies at any point, no matter how much time is left on your current policy. If you're thinking about moving to Staten Island or are wondering if you're paying the best rate for your current area, take 10 minutes and visit Compare.com to find out for sure.

Find your best rate in just a few minutes