Auto Insurance Companies

Car insurance companies in the U.S. offer a wide range of coverages and it can be difficult to know who can best serve your insurance needs. In order to help you decide on a policy that is right for you, we’ve put together some information on over 50 car insurance companies so you can make an informed decision that may save you money. Take a moment and read through the profiles below to determine which company will provide the best car insurance coverage for you and your loved ones. And when you’re done, compare auto insurance quotes to find the best deals in your area.

Compare.com’s List of Car Insurance Companies

21st Century Insurance

21st Century Insurance

Part of the Farmers Insurance Group of Companies®, with over 55 years’ experience in car insurance they have over 50,000 agents across the US.

Learn More...
AALL Auto Insurance

AALL Auto Insurance

They have more than 25 locations across Arizona and over 30 years' experience with a range of payment options.

Learn More...
Acuity Insurance

Acuity Insurance

Acuity has been focused on providing the protection people need for over 90 years, with the help of eager and knowledgeable employees who are ready to clarify every detail of insurance.

Learn More...
Amica Mutual Insurance

Amica Mutual Insurance

With multiple customer satisfaction awards and an A++ (superior) rating from A.M. Best Company, they are a company that you can trust.

Learn More...
Amigo MGA Auto Insurance

Amigo MGA Auto Insurance

Amigo MGA was launched in 2009 and is committed to high quality insurance. Amigo MGA paired up with local independent agents across the US, who have an extensive knowledge of the insurance industry.

Learn More...
Anchor General Insurance

Anchor General Insurance

Based in California, their 20 years of experience and flexible payment plans make them the obvious choice for high-risk drivers.

Learn More...
Arrowhead Insurance

Arrowhead Insurance

Established in 1983, Arrowhead support a range of charities, provide bilingual services for their customers and offer a range of discounts.

Learn More...
Aspire General Insurance

Aspire General Insurance

They specialize in providing insurance to non-standard, price-conscious customers without compromising on service.

Learn More...
Auto Insurance America

Auto Insurance America

With over four decades of experience, you can buy your policy online and benefit from a range of available discounts.

Learn More...
California Casualty

California Casualty

With over 100 years of experience, their 99% customer service satisfaction rating speaks for itself.

Learn More...
Carnegie General Insurance Agency

Carnegie General Insurance Agency

Carnegie General specializes in non-standard coverage and attribute their success to their focus on excellent customer service, offering low down-payments and a range of payment options to suit your budget.

Learn More...
Commonwealth Casualty Auto Insurance

Commonwealth Casualty Auto Insurance

A modern insurance company, they can tailor your policy to suit you whether you have a clean record or have a few tickets.

Learn More...
Dairyland Auto Insurance

Dairyland Auto Insurance

A subsidiary of Sentry insurance, who can boast over 100 years in the business, specializing in non-standard insurance.

Learn More...
Dashers Insurance

Dashers Insurance

Since opening their first office in 1987, they now have more than 25 locations across California with both Spanish and English representatives.

Learn More...
Dillo Insurance

Dillo Insurance

Dillo policies are underwritten by Empower Insurance and Alinsco Insurance, combining experienced underwriting and great customer service.

Learn More...
Direct General Auto Insurance

Direct General Auto Insurance

Founded in 1992 and specializing in non-standard auto insurance, they have over 380 storefronts across the US and over 2,000 employees.

Learn More...
Elephant Auto Insurance

Elephant Auto Insurance

Part of Admiral Group plc, which boasts 11 brands across Europe and the United States, they’re also fully accredited by the Better Business Bureau.

Learn More...
Empower Auto Insurance

Empower Auto Insurance

They have more than 2,000 independent in agents in Texas and are backed by Alinsco's financial strength for more than 40 years.

Learn More...
First Chicago Insurance

First Chicago Insurance

Approaching their 100-year anniversary, they aim to make doing business with them as easy as possible, offering 24/7 claims and good old-fashioned customer service.

Learn More...
Foremost Auto Insurance

Foremost Auto Insurance

Part of the Farmers Group of Companies, they have more than 14,000 claims specialists to help you when you need it most.

Learn More...
Freedom National Auto Insurance

Freedom National Auto Insurance

With over 15 years of experience in auto insurance, all of their services are available in Spanish and you can manage your policy online 24/7.

Learn More...
GAINSCO Auto Insurance

GAINSCO Auto Insurance

They specialize in minimum limits insurance, offering basic coverage with superior service for over 35 years.

Learn More...
Good2Go Auto Insurance

Good2Go Auto Insurance

Atlanta-based with over 25 years’ experience in auto insurance, their mascot, MiniMo is named after their specialization in minimum coverage.

Learn More...
Home State County Mutual Insurance

Home State County Mutual Insurance

All their policies are serviced by Multi-state Insurance Agency, who can boast a strong relationship with local agents for over 60 years.

Learn More...
Horace Mann Insurance

Horace Mann Insurance

Founded by educators for educators, they understand that teachers need specialized coverage without the added paperwork.

Learn More...
Infinity Auto Insurance

Infinity Auto Insurance

With over 12,500 agents to help you when you need it most, they rank among the top 50 property and casualty insurance companies in the US.

Learn More...
Kemper Auto Insurance

Kemper Auto Insurance

Kemper employs more than 6,000 associates and offer 24/7 claims reporting; they even send you text reminders so that you don't miss a payment.

Learn More...
Legacy Auto Insurance

Legacy Auto Insurance

Based in Phoenix, Arizona, they have bilingual agents to ensure that you have excellent customer service whatever you need.

Learn More...
Liberty Mutual Insurance

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Founded in 1912, their claims representatives are available 24/7. They also have local offices in 41 states as well as a free app to manage your policy.

Learn More...
LoneStar MGA Insurance

LoneStar MGA Insurance

With over 10 years experience offering insurance to Texans, they don't use your credit score when determining your premium.

Learn More...
MAPFRE Insurance

MAPFRE Insurance

They operate in over 40 countries across the world and offer bilingual staff here in the US, as well as 24/7 claims handling.

Learn More...
Mendota Auto Insurance

Mendota Auto Insurance

Established in 1989, they have more than 3,600 independent agents across the US and 24/7 claims reporting available.

Learn More...
Mercury Insurance

Mercury Insurance

Voted one of America’s most trustworthy companies by Forbes, they have over 50 years’ experience and employ over 4,500 people.

Learn More...
MetLife Auto & Home

MetLife Auto & Home

With almost 150 years' experience in the insurance industry, they are one of the US' largest carriers with more than 10,000 employees.

Learn More...
Metromile

Metromile

Perfect for city-dwellers or infrequent drivers, their mileage-based coverage means you only pay for what you use.

Learn More...
National General Auto Insurance

National General Auto Insurance

Founded in 1939, they are headquartered in North Carolina and have grown to be one of the largest automobile insurers in the US.

Learn More...
Occidental Insurance

Occidental Insurance

Occidental Insurance has more than 55 years of experience in the insurance business. They cover a range of drivers, whether you have a perfect record or have picked up a couple of tickets, Occidental Insurance provides competitive insurance prices for most drivers.

Learn More...
Plymouth Rock Assurance

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Set up in 1981, they’re part of the Plymouth Rock Group of Companies, which writes and manages over $1 billion in premiums.

Learn More...
Pronto Auto Insurance

Pronto Auto Insurance

They have fully bilingual claims representatives and multiple locations throughout Texas, as well as financial backing from American County Mutual.

Learn More...
Quincy Mutual Group

Quincy Mutual Group

Based in the New England region with more than 500 independent agents, their financial security and excellent service sits them apart from other insurers.

Learn More...
SafeAuto Insurance

SafeAuto Insurance

One of the largest privately owned auto insurers in the US, they have over 20 years’ experience offering high risk drivers’ insurance.

Learn More...
Safeco Insurance

Safeco Insurance

Established in 1923 and part of Liberty Mutual insurance since 2008, they offer 24/7 support and local agents to answer any questions.

Learn More...
Sun Coast General Insurance

Sun Coast General Insurance

With over 30 years of experience, they offer a range of coverages from the basics through to all the bells and whistles, specializing in non-standard coverage.

Learn More...
The General® Auto Insurance

The General® Auto Insurance

Based in Nashville, Tennessee and with over 50 years’ experience they specialize in high risk drivers using their customized rating process.

Learn More...
Topa Insurance

Topa Insurance

Founded in 1981, they are based in L.A. offering policies that are serviced by Multi-state Insurance.

Learn More...
TSC>Direct

TSC>Direct

With over 30 years' experience, their insurance is by New Yorkers for New Yorkers; they know that the big city shouldn't mean big prices.

Learn More...
United Auto Insurance

United Auto Insurance

With over 25 years' experience, this family-owned business invests in the latest technology to make buying insurance easy and efficient.

Learn More...
United Security Auto Insurance

United Security Auto Insurance

An A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and over 45 years' experience in insurance, they are a sister company to First Chicago Insurance.

Learn More...
Western Star Auto Insurance

Western Star Auto Insurance

Western Star offers car insurance through Foremost Insurance Group, who has more than 60 years of insurance experience. Western Star has less than 20 employees, so you will get the individual, personalized attention that you would expect from a family-run business.

Learn More...
Workmen’s Auto Insurance Company

Workmen’s Auto Insurance Company

For over 65 years Workmen’s Auto Insurance has provided California drivers with competitively-priced automobile insurance featuring a range of coverage options and multiple ways to pay.

Learn More...
Compare Car Insurance Quotes