Finding the Right Car Insurance Company
We've reviewed dozens of the country's top insurance companies so that you can find the right one for you and your vehicle.
Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.
Excellent
Been here before? Get your quotes back.
Updated
Why You Can Trust Compare.com: At Compare.com, it’s our mission to find simple ways to help our customers save money on the things they need. While we partner with some of the companies and brands we talk about in our articles, all of our content is written and reviewed by our independent editorial team and never influenced by our partnerships. Learn about how we make money, review our editorial standards, and reference our data methodology to learn more about why you can trust Compare.com.
Advertiser Disclosure
At Compare.com, it’s our mission to give you the tools to find the best (and most affordable) insurance for your unique needs and budget. We strive to provide information that’s helpful, clear, and unbiased, and we believe that comparing insurance companies should never put you at risk of spam. Our editorial team — which is made up of experienced writers, editors, insurance agents, and data analysts — has spent thousands of hours researching and creating the coverage overviews, side-by-side comparisons, and detailed reviews you see across our site.
While we make money through partnerships with some of the brands we discuss in our articles, our editorial team operates 100% independently, and these partners never influence or affect the topics, reviews, ratings, or recommendations we provide. We never guarantee favorable reviews or mentions in exchange for compensation from any brands or partners, and we uphold strict editorial standards to ensure our content is always independent, truthful, and unbiased.
Car insurance companies in the U.S. offer a wide range of options and it can be difficult to know who will offer you the best coverage. In order to help you find a policy that’s right for you, we’ve put together some information on over 50 car insurance companies that we directly work with so you can make an informed decision that may save you money.
Browse through the car insurance company list below and determine which companies will provide the best auto insurance plan for you and your loved ones. When you’re finished, compare your car insurance quotes to find the best deals in your area. To make things easier, you can either buy online or call directly to the insurance provider.
If a company is not listed below, they’re not currently on our panel. However, this is the best time to make sure the other guys are truly getting you the cheapest car insurance. Compare rates from over 50 car insurance companies and see just how much you could save. You might be surprised!
Company  | Description |
|---|---|
| 21st Century Insurance is part of Farmers' large network of insurance companies, but it's no longer offering policies to new customers. |
| AAA Insurance | AAA is known for its world-renowned roadside assistance memberships, but is it a great choice for car insurance, too? Find out with our latest review. |
| Acuity Insurance | Acuity has been focused on providing the protection people need for over 90 years, with the help of eager and knowledgeable employees who are ready to clarify every detail of insurance. |
| AIS Insurance | Looking for car insurance at AIS? Our guide will help you learn what AIS Insurance has to offer and whether it's a good fit for what you need. |
| Allstate | With its competitive rates and excellent variety of coverages, Allstate is a great option for all types of drivers. The company insures high-risk drivers, while also offering low rates and extra discounts to those with clean records. |
| American Alliance Insurance | As a high-risk auto insurer, American Alliance may be a good (or the only) option for some Illinois drivers. But is it right for you? Our latest review covers everything you need to know about American Alliance Insurance |
| American Family | The average American Family policyholder spends $94 per month, but some pay a lot less. We uncover all the details to help you know if AmFam is right for you. |
| Amica Insurance | With multiple customer satisfaction awards and an A+ rating from AM Best Company, they are a company you can trust. |
| Anchor General Insurance | Anchor General rarely turns away drivers with bad driving records or poor credit. You’ll need to get a quote and purchase your Anchor General insurance policy through a third party, but you’ll work with Anchor for claims and customer service. While there isn’t a mobile app, the website offers decent functionality (though some reviews express payment processing issues). |
| Arrowhead Insurance | Arrowhead offers plenty of discounts and insurance products to get you fully covered for less — even for drivers with less-than-perfect driving records. But it can be difficult to get in touch with agents (unless you use the online chat) or manage the claims process. |
| Aspire Insurance | They specialize in providing insurance to non-standard, price-conscious customers without compromising on service. |
| Auto-Owners Insurance | Auto-Owners sets itself apart from other mid-size insurers thanks to useful optional insurance products like purchase price guarantee and rental car coverage. Drivers on a budget should consider Auto-Owners because of its below-average rates, especially if they have an accident or ticket on record. |
| Bristol West Insurance | Part of Farmers Insurance Group, they've been in business for more than 40 years ready to help drivers across the US. |
| California Casualty Auto Insurance | With over 100 years of experience, their 99% customer service satisfaction rating speaks for itself. |
| Chubb | Chubb can be a great fit for drivers with high-value vehicles and people who need higher coverage limits than those offered in standard car insurance policies. But you can’t get a quote or buy a policy online, and the company offers policies in only a handful of states. |
| Clearcover Insurance | Clearcover offers low rates to teens and young drivers — a big selling point since this group tends to pay some of the highest rates. But customer satisfaction levels are low, so be sure to do your due diligence before deciding if Clearcover is right for you. |
| CONNECT Powered by American Family Insurance | CONNECT offers a solid range of coverage options and discounts with above-average customer satisfaction. But is it right for you? |
| COUNTRY Financial | COUNTRY Financial excels at customer service and offers a solid range of coverage options and discounts on its already inexpensive policies. Its huge range of insurance products makes it ideal for one-stop shoppers in search of a bundling discount. But its app and website user experience may lag behind some competitors, and it’s available in only 19 states. |
| Dairyland Auto Insurance | You can easily self-manage your Dairyland policy and access a wide range of coverage options, including special equipment coverage. But discount opportunities are slim, and the company remains unrated by organizations like J.D. Power. |
| Direct Auto Insurance | Direct Auto is a great option if you’ve struggled to find insurance coverage elsewhere because of your driving record, but it’s important to get multiple quotes to make sure it offers the best rate. |
| Elephant Insurance | Part of Admiral Group plc, which boasts 11 brands across Europe and the United States, they’re also fully accredited by the Better Business Bureau. |
| Empower Auto Insurance | They have more than 2,000 independent in agents in Texas and are backed by Alinsco's financial strength for more than 40 years. |
| Encompass Insurance | Part of the Allstate Corporation, they have more than 120 years' experience in the industry, ensuring that they offer their customers "protection and security". |
| Erie Insurance | Erie Insurance has been serving customers since 1925 and currently offers coverage in 13 states. Learn more about what they have to offer. |
| Esurance | Esurance stopped offering new policies in 2023, but existing customers may still be considering new options. Find out if it’s time to switch. |
| Farmers Insurance | With more than 90 years in the insurance industry and nearly 50,000 licensed agents, Farmers Insurance has the experience and know-how to cover you in any situation. |
| First American Insurance | Insure your belongings with a Renters policy to make sure that your possessions are covered, whether you're renting a trailer or a mansion. |
| GAINSCO Auto Insurance | GAINSCO may be the best option for drivers who have difficulty getting a policy elsewhere — the company rarely turns people away. But getting a customized policy takes time and several steps. Plus, customer ratings are generally low. |
| GEICO | GEICO is a great choice for drivers with good driving records who want to save money on their car insurance. It’s also suitable for high-risk drivers, but they should be prepared to pay higher rates because of previous infractions. That said, GEICO might not be for you if you prefer the personal feel of a local agent. |
| Good2Go Insurance | Good2Go may be the best option for drivers who struggle to get a policy elsewhere and who need proof of insurance coverage. But with nearly five times the number of complaints compared to similarly sized companies, Good2Go may have trouble serving its customers. |
| Hallmark Financial | Hallmark’s coverage is limited to a handful of states, but it can offer savings to drivers with accidents and tickets on their records. Online feedback on customer service is generally positive, but recent claims and experiences suggest things could be slipping. |
| Home State County Mutual Insurance | Their home State is Texas, so they know what Texans really need in their car insurance policies: great coverage at a low price. |
| Horace Mann Insurance | Founded by educators for educators, they understand that teachers need specialized coverage without the added paperwork. |
| Hugo Auto Insurance | Insurance newcomer Hugo may not be as cheap as some insurers, but the company’s revolutionary “on-demand model” provides unrivaled flexibility that makes it a great fit for many drivers. |
| Infinity Auto Insurance | If you want no-frills auto insurance coverage at an affordable price, Infinity Auto Insurance could be just what you’re looking for. But with limited availability, discounts, and coverage options, it may not be the right fit for everyone. |
| Kemper Insurance | Kemper has lower-than-average customer satisfaction ratings, and many users complain about a poor claims process, but it may be an affordable option for high-risk drivers. |
| Lemonade Insurance | Lemonade car insurance excels for tech-savvy, environmentally conscious drivers who value innovative insurance models and social responsibility. But it may be less ideal for those requiring broad geographic coverage or specific services like rideshare insurance. |
| Liberty Mutual | Founded in 1912, their claims representatives are available 24/7. They also have local offices in 41 states as well as a free app to manage your policy. |
| Lonestar MGA Insurance | With over 10 years experience offering insurance to Texans, they don't use your credit score when determining your premium. |
| MAPFRE Insurance | They operate in over 40 countries across the world and offer bilingual staff here in the US, as well as 24/7 claims handling. |
| Mercury Insurance | Voted one of America’s most trustworthy companies by Forbes, they have over 50 years’ experience and employ over 4,500 people. |
| Metromile | Metromile is a good option for people who drive less than 7,500 miles annually, but hidden charges can decrease savings. |
| Mile Auto | Mile Auto is an Atlanta-based insurance company founded in 2017. The company got its start by securing $10.3 million in seed funding. Today they pride themselves on offering affordable pay-per-mile auto insurance which they claim can save drivers 30-40% on their premiums. |
| National General Insurance | You’ll find low rates, rare coverage options, and premium insurance options at National General, but customer service issues may outweigh the benefits for some. |
| Nationwide | Nationwide is one of the largest car insurance agencies in the U.S. Find out how much money you can save and if its coverage is right for you. |
| NJM Insurance | NJM Auto Insurance has been serving drivers for over 100 years with a reputation for quality service and coverage. |
| NYCM Insurance | Based in Central New York, their 24-hour helplines cement them as a real advocate for the customer; you can even access your information online or via their free app. |
| Occidental Insurance | Occidental Insurance has more than 55 years of experience in the insurance business. They cover a range of drivers, whether you have a perfect record or have picked up a couple of tickets, Occidental Insurance provides competitive insurance prices for most drivers. |
| Plymouth Rock Assurance | Plymouth Rock offers a wide variety of coverage options with competitive monthly rates. Learn more about how Plymouth Rock works and whether it’s right for you. |
| Progressive | Progressive is one of several national insurers that offer 24/7 customer care, an easy-to-use mobile app, and competitive pricing — even to drivers considered high-risk. It offers a wide range of auto coverage options, but price hikes may eventually occur, regardless of driving record changes. |
| Pronto Auto Insurance | They have fully bilingual claims representatives and multiple locations throughout Texas, as well as financial backing from American County Mutual. |
| Quincy Mutual Group | Based in the New England region with more than 500 independent agents, their financial security and excellent service sets them apart from other insurers. |
| Root Insurance | Root can provide affordable coverage for drivers who live in states where the insurer offers coverage, provided they do well on its test-drive. But some drivers won’t qualify, and actually getting a final price on coverage can be a long and complicated process. |
| SafeAuto Insurance | One of the largest privately owned auto insurers in the US, they have over 20 years’ experience offering high risk drivers ’ insurance. |
| Safeco Insurance | Established in 1923 and part of Liberty Mutual insurance since 2008, Safeco offers 24/7 support and local agents to answer any questions. |
| Say Insurance Review | A modern take on car insurance, their parent company Shelter Insurance has more than 70 years' experience in the insurance industry. |
| SECURA Insurance | SECURA offers cheap car insurance (even for drivers with a DUI) and has a highly regarded customer service team. But recent reviews signal potential trouble with the company’s claims process. And unfortunately, the company stopped taking on new customers in 2023. |
| State Auto Insurance | State Auto offers unique coverage options through its premium insurance packages, including Total Loss Plus — a benefit that pays 120% of your vehicle’s market value if it’s totaled. Current customers enrolled in these programs or drivers with DUIs may want to stick with the company despite its acquisition by Liberty Mutual. |
| State Farm | Drivers looking for a basic car insurance policy from a company with a solid reputation can find what they need from State Farm. |
Related articles
)
AAA Auto Insurance Review: Is It Right for You?
May 11, 2025
)
Nationwide Car Insurance Review (2025 Rates & Reviews)
May 11, 2025
){kind=logo}
Allstate Auto Insurance Review: A Good Choice?
May 11, 2025
){kind=logo}
GEICO Auto Insurance Review: Is It Right for You? (2024)
May 11, 2025
)
USAA Review: The Best Choice for Car Insurance?
May 11, 2025
)
Travelers Insurance Review: A Good Choice for Car Insurance?
October 11, 2023
)
Farmers Insurance Review: The Best Choice for You? | Compare
May 11, 2025
){kind=logo}
State Farm Auto Insurance Review: Is it the Best Choice?
May 11, 2025
)
)
)
)
)